Myers it is generally accepted that the revival of american interest in the traditional concept of the just war began sometime during the undeclared war in. Augustine and his views on just war the extent to which a christian can and ought to participate in war. Kosovo and the just war tradition commonwealth institute. A main differences that emerges between christian and prechristian just war theory are the beliefs relating to the interaction with, and rights of the enemy. Following the 911 terrorist attacks, america began a war against terrorism. Just war theory posted on 14 february 2016 aquinas follows medieval legal thinkers in defining the conditions under which war may be justified, and proposes his famous doctrine of double effect. Just war theory is typically considered to be an essential rightsbased or deontological theory. Within the academic world of war politics, there are heterogeneous perspectives, such as pacifism and realism etc. Augustine and his views on just war the extent to which a christian can and ought to participate in war and likewise the limits. This is a body of thought that seeks to provide guidelines for when it is justified for one nation to wage war on another.
This idea of a just war only being fought as a last resort is a central belief that persists throughout the adoption of just war theory in christianity. The theory of the just war deals with the justification of the war jus ad bellum and how it must be fought jus in bello to respect the moral principles which govern our individual or. Nov 30, 2015 within just war theory, the moral issues surrounding war are traditionally divided into two main categories. Thomas aquinas provided the most celebrated and still discussed the main outlines of just war theory. This is hardly surprising because the just war tradition is a complex one, which has evolved over the course of more than 1,500 years. Jus ad bellum concerns the justification for the resort to war in the first place, a. In addition, some scholars have recently considered a third criteria, jus post bellum, right conduct after war. The just war theory is an attempt to distill moral principles into guidelines relevant to warfare. The one big drawback here is that regan fails to weave just war theory and development into part two.
A war which might be regarded as justifiable both in terms of going to war and the way it is fought. It is thus about a moral reflection on the goals and the means of the war starting. Just war theory was relegated to religion departments, theological seminaries, and a few catholic universities. Indeed, he uses this classic theory to expose contemporary misunderstandings of just war criteria. The just war theory forum is an open resource for everyone concerned with issues of war, peace, justice, and reason. Just war theory is a doctrine of military ethics of roman philosophical and catholic origin studied by moral theologians, ethicists and international policy makers which holds that a conflict can and ought to meet certain conditions. The arguments presented here will presuppose the cogency of the latter, conditional normative critique of bush doctrine preventive military policies. Augustines views on the just war in the church and war.
Pdf augustine and the just war theory joelle e lucas academia. The triumph of just war theory school of social science. Just war theory and nonstate actors auburn university. To the extent that this is interpreted as a legitimate government, this leaves little room for revolutionary war or civil war, in which an illegitimate entity may declare war for reasons that fit the remaining criteria of just war theory. Augustine commented on the morality of war from a christian perspective, as did several arabic commentators from the 9th to the 12th centuries. Johnson a nyone seriously interested in applying tra ditional just war theory to current interna tional affairs finds it difficult even to begin. History the just war theory was asserted as an authoritative catholic. A critique of just war theory by benjamin studebaker. Traditionalists, along with international law, roughly hold that all.
Throughout the seminar, it continued to strike me that just war theory in and of itself is. Rethinking the just war, part 1 the new york times. Obama on just war doctrine and emergence of unconventional warfare duration. Pdf augustine and the just war theory joelle e lucas.
Aug 01, 2017 concepts from augustines just war theory may be seen in regulations within nato, the united nations, and the u. This revisionist conception has various heterodoxindeed, hereticalimplications that i will highlight and defend. Instead we are given a brief historical look at the wars in question. That is, in standard just war theory, a distinction is drawn between jus ad bellumwhether the war is, in principle, justifiedand jus in bellowhether the means used to carry it out are justified.
This essay provides a brief overview of the just war tradition and then applies the framework to the problem of contemporary terrorism. Set of terms examining just war theory in texts and traditions. However, just war theory also acts to remind contenders that war is a last resort and that its essential aim is always peace, so if peace is forthcoming in any guise, it is morally critical for all parties to seek a return to a permanent peace rather than a momentary lapse of war. But some have a long life in this world, a history most often of service to the powersthatbe, but also, sometimes, an oppositionist history. Just war theory and the laws of war as nonidentical twins.
The goal of the just war theory is to identify when it is morally acceptable to support a particular conflict. Long before the shock and awe campaign against iraq in march 2003, debates swarmed around the justifications of the u. War attacks people rights to life, security, peace, and liberty. First, are the justifying principles for why war is waged jus ad bello just cause. This is intended for gcse students its not detailed enough for the a level course. Popular war and just war theory books showing 150 of 331 the force of nonviolence. Just war theory suggests that under certain conditions it is possible to be be morally justified. Just war theory deals with the justification of how and why wars are fought. The triumph of just war theory and the dangers of success. Kant is often cited as one of the first truly international political philosophers. We are not here to fight something or tear something down. The first is from an encyclopedia of war and ethics and the second is an online source from the stanford encyclopedia of philosophy.
Oct 30, 2006 thank you for kenneth himes article hard questions about just war october 30. Today i had a seminar on just war theory, the theory of when it is justifiable for one state to go to war with another. From a christian standpoint, this means applying biblical ideas to create those practical standards. The reader would be better served if the author had shown how the just war theory related to the action. And even in those places, isolated as they were from the political world, the theory was pressed toward. On the one hand, the theory contains a theory of public war wherein ethical responsibility for the justice of war belongs uniquely to political sovereigns while subjects, including soldiers, are obligated to serve in war upon the sovereigns command. Just war theory is probably the most influential perspective on the ethics of war and peace. In fact, just war ideals shaped the geneva convention and other international agreements, as well as helping to shape army regulations in the. Although it was extensively developed by christian theologians, it. Kants just war theory 3z5 reflects on the contributions of traditional just war theorists and arrives at the following judgment.
The just war tradition has enjoyed a long and distinguished pedigree, including such notables as augustine, aquinas, grotius, suarez, vattel and vitoria. As a result the theory does not satisfy many of the criteria of chapter 2 that theories are supposed to possess. Notes on just war theory ever just or just for whom. Judith butler shelved 1 time as war and justwartheory avg rating 4. The theory of just war began in the service of the powers. Long before the shock and awe campaign against iraq in m. Whether or not the iraq war should be regarded as a just war or just a war has been sparked a lot of academic and public debates since 2003. An open invitation to web discussions on the conditions of just war theory is extended to all. War is defined by the merriamwebster dictionary as a state of usually open and declared armed hostile conflict between states or nations. In this five part series on the christian just war tradition well examine the three main areas of just war theory. Just war theory internet encyclopedia of philosophy.
All that exists is a just war tradition, not a single precise and explicit doctrine of an international body, government, treaty, church, or moral theory. Just war is a western concept and should be distinguished from the islamic concept of jihad arabic. Just war theory and christianity the bible and comparative. Central to this conflict with traditional just war theory is the moral equality of combatants. This paper chose to analyse the issue by the employment of the just war theory. Jul 20, 2006 against the theory of the just war against the theory of the just war. It deals not with ethics as a whole, but with a small cluster of ethical issues. Conventional modern just war theory is fundamentally incoherent. Just war ideas before augustine while war is hell, war is a reality in our world. On the other hand, the theory contains a theory of discrimination which. Concepts from augustines just war theory may be seen in regulations within nato, the united nations, and the u. After briefly discussing aspects of the tradition of just war theory, i turn to rawlss. The questions are many and difficult, as well as enormously pressing in todays usa.
But i place it here for its apposite discussion of the wars in afghanistan and iraq. The bush doctrine as a hegemonic discourse strategy. This essay examines the similarities, but even more the dissimilarities, between nonrevisionist just war theory and the laws of war. The just war theory provides a basis for laws of war not because war is good but because it must be restricted and brought more and more under control, even while we work for its total abolition. It generated the various arguments of the thinkers. Augustine is noted in history as the founder of just war theory in the western tradition the islamic world has its own tradition of just war theory based on the koran. Myers president of the carnegie council on ethics and international affairs from 1980 to 1995. The purpose of the doctrine is to ensure war is morally justifiable through a series of criteria, all of which must be met for a war to be considered just. Fr claude mostowik msc convenor, pax christi australia nsw photo taken by fr shenouda, general secretary of nsw ecumenical council. It is therefore to be wondered at that the word right has not been completely banished from military politics as superfluous pedantry, and that no state has been bold enough. Introduction to just war theory and word war ii jus in bello and the geneva conventions the principle of good faith and the treatment of prisoners the maintenance of the noncombatantcombatant distinction and its relation to strategical warfare the principle of proportionality in the use of force conclusion bibliography. The theoretical aspect is concerned with ethically justifying war and the forms that warfare may or may not take. Occasionally, skeptics of just war theory will also, for satirical effect, cite instances from the classical literature of causes for war that are now rejected but were once widely accepted as just, such as the punishment of wrongdoing and the spread of the christian religion.
Articles just war theory power that saves us both from that moral excess and that political folly. The just war theory forum is connected to interquest. The evolution of the theory the origin of just war theory is usually traced to the writings of augustine, though many of the theory s elements became well established only much later, during its classical period between the early 16th and mid17th centuries. A collection of objections found in the revisionist work of mcmahan, rodin, and others is currently roiling the just war community. The idea that a war can be justifiable if it follows certain criteria.
It deals with augustines just war theory as being the product of his times, the late roman empire. Just war theory is based on this classical view and from it the central concepts derive. Revolution and civil war just war theory states that a just war must have just authority. Rawls understands the doctrines of just war theory in light of an. Markus notes that, unlike almost all of augustines. Augustines political ideas, this one focusing on his contribution to just war theory. The classical just war framework provides the foundation for customary international law as well as the formal laws of armed conflict, in addition to ethical reflection. Overview the class will explore the concept of a just war and apply their knowledge and opinions to the bombings of hiroshima and nagasaki. Bjorn moller kosovo and the just war tradition page 5 war was generally regarded as a perfectly legitimate means to political ends. Just war theory and the war on terr or 109 downloaded by william calcutt at 01. No matter how right this action might appear to be on the surface, it is incumbent upon christians to ask themselves whether u. Just war theory has a long history in the western intellectual tradition. The principles of just war theory were then understood to be part of a. Some people argue that the just war doctrine is inherently immoral, while others suggest that there is no place for ethics in.
A just peace exists when the human rights of those involved in the war, on both sides, are more secure than they were before the war. The theory of the just war deals with the justification of the war jus ad bellum and how it must be fought jus in bello to respect the moral principles which govern our individual or collective actions. Especially discussion concerning the united states policy towards iraq. The just war theory specifies conditions for judging if it is just to go to war, and conditions for how the war should be fought. The origin of just war theory is usually traced to the writings of augustine, though many of the theorys elements became well established only much later, during its classical period between the early 16 th and mid17 th centuries. Using the principles of just war theory to analyze the main combatants of wwii. A special part of the interest of just war theory is that it is built on a long and rich historical development, just as a special part of the interest of the just war tradition is that it is the history. Thus, through first a negative argument against current conceptions of kants views of just war theory, and then a positive argument for kants general philosophical approach and a. The lineage of just war theory dates several thousand years, with the most recent millennium seeing the body of knowledge mature into its current version. The lesson asks students to consider the six princi ples of jus ad bellum, or what makes a war just, as applied to world war ii. An armed conflict occurring between two different states or parties. The first establishing jus ad bellum, the right to go to war.
The dualism of modern just war theory springerlink. Be able to form an opinion as to whether they think hiroshima and nagasaki fit with just war theory. The justification can be either theoretical or historical. The just war theory the just war theory is and interesting one simply because the phrase just war is an oxymoron. Mar 02, 2010 aquinas premesis for the just war theory. Just war theory provides normative content for ethical arguments about the resort to and conduct of war on the assumption, distinct from realism, that morality has a place in international politicsalthough like realism, it assumes that war is an enduring feature of world politics. I end with an application of kants just war theory to previous conflicts, as a demonstration of the practical value of this view. The dissimilarities derive from the special character of law. Yet, as we have defined it here as the attempt to distinguish between ethical justifiable and unjustifiable uses of organized armed forces one might take a utilitarian approach to just war theory instead.
Just war, notion that the resort to armed force jus ad bellum is justified under certain conditions. Jus in bello and the geneva conventions just war theory. Jus in bello even in the case of wars that meet all the jus ad bellum criteria, the other set of criteria remains in force. Just war theory sets forth standards, both jus ad bellum rules governing if a war may be fought and jus in bello rules governing how a war is fought, standards which must be met if a war is to be considered just. Jus post bellum, just peace, just war theory, human rights the just war tradition is based on the paradox that killing may be necessary to save. Part of the problem is that the theory itself is badly misunderstood. This lesson introduces students to the principles of just war theory, the basis of international agreements such as the geneva conventions that regulate the conduct of nations in wartime. Just war theory has been criticized since it so often is employed by governments and political leadership to justify uses of violent force for nationalistic, political selfserving or otherwise nonmoral reasons.
315 372 1363 188 864 18 1597 46 1196 615 1627 212 49 1431 1398 792 1400 281 202 638 440 506 631 1308 1598 75 1637 993 500 1500 1323 684 53 1098 956 1104 1135 939 802 735 394 802 1375